The music industry has always extracted more from women than it has returned. This is the baseline fact around which everything else must be organised. And the second fact, which is inseparable from the first: women have kept making extraordinary music anyway, in conditions of exploitation and constraint that would have stopped most artists, producing work that has defined genres, changed cultures, and outlasted every executive who underestimated them.
The history of women in music is a history of two forces operating simultaneously: the music and the machine. The music almost always wins.
The Blues and What Came After
Bessie Smith recorded “Downhearted Blues” in 1923 and sold over 800,000 copies in six months — at a time when 800,000 copies was an almost inconceivable number. She was the highest-paid Black performer in America and she spent it as fast as she made it, on parties and clothes and a private railroad car, on her terms, which was the only way she operated. Columbia Records dropped her in 1931 as the Depression hit the recording industry. She continued performing until her death in a car accident in 1937.
Ma Rainey — the Mother of the Blues — was recording before Smith, from 1923, bringing to the phonograph a sound and a vision of female experience — sexual, independent, unsentimental — that the music industry hadn’t encountered and wasn’t sure what to do with. Her “Prove It on Me Blues” (1928) is an explicit expression of lesbian desire, released commercially and listened to commercially in 1928. The music industry’s moral guardians apparently didn’t recognise what they were hearing.
Billie Holiday is the example everyone reaches for and she belongs here. “Strange Fruit” (1939) — written by Abel Meeropol, adapted and performed by Holiday — is not just one of the great recordings in American music. It is one of the great political acts in American cultural history: a Black woman, in a white-owned nightclub in New York, performing a song about the lynching of Black men with such stillness and authority that the room could not pretend it hadn’t heard. Holiday was surveilled by the FBI, had her drug charges weaponised against her repeatedly, and was denied a cabaret licence in the last years of her life that would have allowed her to perform in New York clubs. She died in 1959 with less than a dollar in her bank account.
The Pop Architects
Carole King co-wrote, with Gerry Goffin, some of the most successful pop songs of the early 1960s — “Will You Love Me Tomorrow,” “One Fine Day,” “(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman” — mostly for other artists, because female songwriters wrote for other people rather than for themselves. Her own album Tapestry (1971), written during her divorce and recorded with her children present in the studio, became one of the best-selling albums of all time and spent 15 weeks at number one. It remains one of the most intimate, formally precise, emotionally direct popular music recordings ever made.
Joni Mitchell is the case study in what happens when a female musician with the level of compositional ambition usually reserved for male jazz and classical musicians enters the pop music world. She was permitted to succeed in a singer-songwriter box, in folk rock, in singer-pianist categories. When she pushed into jazz fusion, into avant-garde arrangements, she was praised by other musicians and received with confusion by the industry. The triple album The Hissing of Summer Lawns (1975) is one of the great records of its decade by any artist; its critical reception at the time was lukewarm. Her reputation has been in process of correction ever since.
The Revolution in Sound
Aretha Franklin’s voice is the argument for itself. But the story around the voice is also instructive: Franklin recorded for Columbia for six years in the early 1960s, packaged by producer John Hammond as a mainstream pop singer, which suppressed rather than showcased what she could do. When she signed with Atlantic in 1966 and producer Jerry Wexler took her to FAME Studios in Muscle Shoals, Alabama, what happened was the single greatest sequence of recordings in American popular music. “I Never Loved a Man (The Way I Love You),” “Respect,” “Chain of Fools,” “Think” — recorded in two years, 1967-1968, and still the standard against which soul music is measured.
The word “Respect” had been written by Otis Redding about a man demanding respect from his woman at home. Aretha rewrote it as a woman demanding respect from the world. The second version is the only one anyone remembers.
The Industry Women Built and the Industry That Took From Them
The history of women in music is punctuated by examples of female artists who built audiences and institutions that were then appropriated, exploited, or written out of the record.
Florence Ballard, an original member of the Supremes, was pushed out by Motown Records in 1967, replaced by Cindy Birdsong, and left without legal recourse because the contracts she’d signed as a teenager gave her almost no rights. She died in 1976 at 32.
The riot grrrl movement of the early 1990s — Bikini Kill, Sleater-Kinney, Hole, PJ Harvey — created a feminist punk subculture that explicitly addressed the music industry’s treatment of women, the media’s treatment of female musicians, and the ways female anger had been excluded from rock music. The movement produced some of the most important rock music of the decade and was almost immediately commodified — “women in rock” as a marketing category in 1994 followed riot grrrl like a shadow.
Beyoncé and the Economics of Control
Beyoncé’s career after Lemonade (2016) is a case study in what female musical authority looks like when it has the economic power to enforce itself. Lemonade was released without advance notice, via Tidal and HBO, bypassing the usual industry apparatus. It was a visual album about infidelity, about Black female pain, about Jay-Z — specific enough to be autobiography, universal enough to be claimed by millions of women who had no specific knowledge of the Carters’ marriage.
Renaissance (2022) was an explicit act of cultural homage — to Black queer electronic and dance music, to ballroom culture, to the artists who made these traditions and were systematically excluded from mainstream recognition. The album’s liner notes were instruction: these are the people who built what I’m building on. Look them up.
Cowboy Carter (2024) was country music approached as an act of reclamation — a Black woman in a genre that had its roots in Black musical tradition before being whitened and corporatised, asserting her right to the full inheritance of American music. The resistance from country music’s gatekeepers was instructive. So was the audience’s response.
Who Is Doing the Most Important Work in 2026
Arooj Aftab is the most significant artist currently working at the intersection of classical, jazz, and Sufi music. Her album Vulture Prince (2021) introduced ghazal to a global indie and jazz audience without sanitising or simplifying the form. Her Grammy win for Best Global Music Performance was a genuine institutional recognition of work that is genuinely extraordinary. The follow-up Night Reign (2024) extended the vision.
Amaarae is building a new global pop that integrates Ghanaian Afrobeats, R&B, and electronic production with a queer feminist perspective that is specific to her and belongs to no existing category.
Ethel Cain — Hayden Anhedonia — is making the most ambitious American folk music currently recorded: gothic, Southern, explicitly critical of religious patriarchy, produced with a theatrical scope that has no precedent in the genre.
Yemi Alade has been doing this for a decade but deserves a wider audience: Afropop at the level of genuine craft and political consciousness, made with consistent excellence.
Lana Del Rey is, critically speaking, far more interesting than her reputation allows. Her late albums — Norman Fucking Rockwell, Chemtrails Over the Country Club — are not pop records. They are concept albums about American mythology and its casualties, made with Joni Mitchell’s compositional intelligence and the production sophistication of the best of 1960s and 70s orchestral pop.
The music women are making in 2026 cannot be confined to any single tradition. It is drawing from everything: from ghazal and gospel and grime and country and jazz and electronic, from every corner of the world’s musical inheritance. What connects it is not gender but the authority of the people making it — the refusal, after centuries of being told to write for other artists or accept terms set by others or be grateful for the space they were allowed — to accept anything less than full creative ownership.
Related reading: